Oh, my.
I added the WordPress Facebook Application a few days ago. Now my blog, and your comments, are showing up on my Facebook Profile Page. Along with my Twitters. My Flickr photos. My Google Reader items. My Kyte videos. And a bunch of other things.
Jeremiah Owyang is sitting here with me and he’s the one who said it’s a black hole after seeing how Facebook is becoming the new portal for all information you post around the Web. He wrote a post titled “all your widgets are belong to Facebook.”
Other evidence that Facebook is a black hole, sucking stuff into it: They just acquired Parakey, a stealth-mode startup started by Blake Ross and Joe Hewitt, two former Firefox geeks.
Another concern, apart from my post is that these third party developers (like the wordpress one) now have access to your blog, and they are not affiliated with wordpress.
What’s stopping them from doing something devious? slipping in some light SEO code? or putting up a goatze?
On the other hand, when I see several of my friends using one application (and facebook is great for that) my level of trust goes up, as I see my peers using it.
Trade offs either way.
Another concern, apart from my post is that these third party developers (like the wordpress one) now have access to your blog, and they are not affiliated with wordpress.
What’s stopping them from doing something devious? slipping in some light SEO code? or putting up a goatze?
On the other hand, when I see several of my friends using one application (and facebook is great for that) my level of trust goes up, as I see my peers using it.
Trade offs either way.
I’m still not getting why people insist that facebook, as a platform, is a “closed system”, am I missing something???
A)anyone can develop apps on said system, no need for authorization
B)anyone can access information from their users and display it on an external site, of course not all-data is available, but that would make no sense because of the privacy issues
There are certain parts of FB that of course aren’t open (like the user’s profiles outside of FB)but that’s FB the site, not FB the platform.
Jeremiah: I don’t know how that wordpress app is implemented, but if it’s just crawling the feed of your blog it can’t really write anything on it or access any information that isn’t already public. The developer could however “put up a goatze” on your profile box, but that’s as far as it gets (I realize it would be pretty bad, but I guess you should only install apps if you trust the developer as on any system). As for SEO code, first I don’t think google indexes or could index user’s profiles and also FB caches anything that goes on the profile boxes so they wouldn’t allow it).
peace,
mario romero
I’m still not getting why people insist that facebook, as a platform, is a “closed system”, am I missing something???
A)anyone can develop apps on said system, no need for authorization
B)anyone can access information from their users and display it on an external site, of course not all-data is available, but that would make no sense because of the privacy issues
There are certain parts of FB that of course aren’t open (like the user’s profiles outside of FB)but that’s FB the site, not FB the platform.
Jeremiah: I don’t know how that wordpress app is implemented, but if it’s just crawling the feed of your blog it can’t really write anything on it or access any information that isn’t already public. The developer could however “put up a goatze” on your profile box, but that’s as far as it gets (I realize it would be pretty bad, but I guess you should only install apps if you trust the developer as on any system). As for SEO code, first I don’t think google indexes or could index user’s profiles and also FB caches anything that goes on the profile boxes so they wouldn’t allow it).
peace,
mario romero
This is interesting. Wondered something similar when i hooked up WP this morning. I wonder if we have to think about horizontal social networks, such as FB as aggregators, and vertical networks such as WP, or Lending Club, as capabilities that folks will pull into their horizontal networks. I’ll stop there before my brain explodes.
This is interesting. Wondered something similar when i hooked up WP this morning. I wonder if we have to think about horizontal social networks, such as FB as aggregators, and vertical networks such as WP, or Lending Club, as capabilities that folks will pull into their horizontal networks. I’ll stop there before my brain explodes.
[...] he says Facebook is a black [...]
Oh my god! Facebook again, you should working for Facebook, I think.
Oh my god! Facebook again, you should working for Facebook, I think.
“Oh my god! Facebook again, you should working for Facebook, I think.”
Yeah, I miss the Robert Scoble that went on a no “GYM” binge and pointed out that Techmeme tends to aggregate popular/press release stories over the little guy.
At least he straight up admits that he plans to talk about Facebook and the iPhone as much as he wants. On the bright side, it’s there are PodTech videos thrown in the mix.
Basically, Scobleizer@Microsoft > Scobleizer@Podtech.
“Oh my god! Facebook again, you should working for Facebook, I think.”
Yeah, I miss the Robert Scoble that went on a no “GYM” binge and pointed out that Techmeme tends to aggregate popular/press release stories over the little guy.
At least he straight up admits that he plans to talk about Facebook and the iPhone as much as he wants. On the bright side, it’s there are PodTech videos thrown in the mix.
Basically, Scobleizer@Microsoft > Scobleizer@Podtech.
[...] been said on what the acquisition means for Facebook in the broader sense. Robert Scoble says that Facebook is the new data black whole, noting that many of his favorite apps are now appearing on Facebook. Facebook is starting to [...]
Mario
The wordpress app requires you to login to your wordpress account from their app. This means they know your wordpress account info.
This means they could modify your blog on wordpress (outside of Facebook)
It’s a semi-closed systems, you can build on top of Facebook, but they still retain a tremendous amount of data you can’t easily export. Be sure to read my post that Scoble linked to.
Mario
The wordpress app requires you to login to your wordpress account from their app. This means they know your wordpress account info.
This means they could modify your blog on wordpress (outside of Facebook)
It’s a semi-closed systems, you can build on top of Facebook, but they still retain a tremendous amount of data you can’t easily export. Be sure to read my post that Scoble linked to.
heh. just saw this a few minutes ago; added links back to you + Jeremiah + Duncan Riley on my Facebook isn’t AOL, it’s Visual Basic post from earlier this evening.
guess we’re all drawing the Facebook = Microsoft analogy, especially those of us who used to drink the MSFT developer koolaid
those were the daze, eh Robert?
(the SDForum Visual Basic SIG still lives on in a special little place in my Borg heart
- dave mcclure
http://500hats.typepad.com/
heh. just saw this a few minutes ago; added links back to you + Jeremiah + Duncan Riley on my Facebook isn’t AOL, it’s Visual Basic post from earlier this evening.
guess we’re all drawing the Facebook = Microsoft analogy, especially those of us who used to drink the MSFT developer koolaid
those were the daze, eh Robert?
(the SDForum Visual Basic SIG still lives on in a special little place in my Borg heart
- dave mcclure
http://500hats.typepad.com/
The WordPress app in Facebook is in an iframe. At no point does Facebook ever get your WordPress.com username and password.
If you login at wordpress.com and then go to the app you’ll skip the app login page entirely.
The WordPress app in Facebook is in an iframe. At no point does Facebook ever get your WordPress.com username and password.
If you login at wordpress.com and then go to the app you’ll skip the app login page entirely.
Dave: great blog post, thanks, I put it on my link blog. I have a special place in my heart for the Visual Basic SIG, too. One speech there has made me more than $100,000 so far.
Dave: great blog post, thanks, I put it on my link blog. I have a special place in my heart for the Visual Basic SIG, too. One speech there has made me more than $100,000 so far.
Robert,
Just read your blog comment on techcrunch. Why do people think it is all hype… guess they have not used facebook and can’t “get it”…
As you said…. Siemens doe s not have thousands of people on facebook if there is no value.
Robert,
Just read your blog comment on techcrunch. Why do people think it is all hype… guess they have not used facebook and can’t “get it”…
As you said…. Siemens doe s not have thousands of people on facebook if there is no value.
Rumford: a couple people admitted at the conference today they are dragging their feet because they are tired of trying to keep up with everything new.
Rumford: a couple people admitted at the conference today they are dragging their feet because they are tired of trying to keep up with everything new.
More evidence that FB is a Black Hole.
Nothing escapes.
FB is hidden behind the login wall. It has almost no RSS. There’s no way to export anything about your friends. And so on.
More evidence that FB is a Black Hole.
Nothing escapes.
FB is hidden behind the login wall. It has almost no RSS. There’s no way to export anything about your friends. And so on.
Yup. I talked about this a month ago or so.
http://tinyurl.com/yqbetp
It’s not just Facebook you know. Closed data silos are something we’ve had for years which is why FB doesn’t excite me.
Yup. I talked about this a month ago or so.
http://tinyurl.com/yqbetp
It’s not just Facebook you know. Closed data silos are something we’ve had for years which is why FB doesn’t excite me.
Steven: Facebook isn’t your father’s closed silo, though.
But, no problem, you’ll get dragged into Facebook eventually even if you resist.
Steven: Facebook isn’t your father’s closed silo, though.
But, no problem, you’ll get dragged into Facebook eventually even if you resist.
Robert – i’m already dragged in (it actually reminds of of Ecademy when i used to use that)
I DO like the idea – but i’m not convinved it’s a platform as such. I like Amazon Web Services or Microsoft Internet Service Bus, OpenID etc – those would be my service platform.
Robert – i’m already dragged in (it actually reminds of of Ecademy when i used to use that)
I DO like the idea – but i’m not convinved it’s a platform as such. I like Amazon Web Services or Microsoft Internet Service Bus, OpenID etc – those would be my service platform.
Joseph
Thanks, just for clarity, (read my comments carefully) I was suggesting that the third party application creator to WordPress has access to Scobleizer.com.
Joseph
Thanks, just for clarity, (read my comments carefully) I was suggesting that the third party application creator to WordPress has access to Scobleizer.com.
[...] been said on what the acquisition means for Facebook in the broader sense. Robert Scoble says that Facebook is the new data black hole, noting that many of his favorite apps are now appearing on Facebook. Facebook is starting to [...]
[...] both Robert Scoble and Jeremiah Owyang are concerned that Facebook is a black hole of data – it all goes in, but [...]
[...] Robert Scoble and Jeremiah Owyang are making this claim. I agree that Facebook doesn’t let data out, but is [...]
Ok, I smell scobie got some juicy offer for IPO stock from facebook and he is contributing to the hype.
Say it ain’t so rob?
Ok, I smell scobie got some juicy offer for IPO stock from facebook and he is contributing to the hype.
Say it ain’t so rob?
[...] been said on what the acquisition means for Facebook in the broader sense. Robert Scoble says that Facebook is the new data black hole, noting that many of his favorite apps are now appearing on Facebook. Facebook is starting to [...]
[...] been said on what the acquisition means for Facebook in the broader sense. Robert Scoble says that Facebook is the new data black hole, noting that many of his favorite apps are now appearing on Facebook. Facebook is starting to [...]
[...] are: when will facebook synch up with LinkedIN? And is facebook the internet equivalent of a ‘Black Hole’? Apparently so, according to Robert Scoble. Perhaps that’s why I’m feeling the [...]
[...] all as Robert’s data gets sucked into the black hole of Facebook he writes off Microsoft as any force to be reckoned with in this brave new shiny world [...]
I don’t know. For me, too many options and too many apps confined in one space. I don’t like being stuck in a closet full of widgets. RSS and tags already bridges me to content that I want, links me to niche experts and relevant conversations.
But then, I’m not an early adapter; and perhaps I will ‘get it’ in a few years when the other 900 million people on the Internet do.
All the best
Tom
I don’t know. For me, too many options and too many apps confined in one space. I don’t like being stuck in a closet full of widgets. RSS and tags already bridges me to content that I want, links me to niche experts and relevant conversations.
But then, I’m not an early adapter; and perhaps I will ‘get it’ in a few years when the other 900 million people on the Internet do.
All the best
Tom
Todays Tech Notes 7/20/2007
Digital DNA could finger Harry Potter leaker A few lines of ‘digital DNA’ could allow the publishers of Harry Potter to find and finger the person apparently responsible for leaking the final adventures of the boy wizard.
Opera Software Op…
I love Facebook. And I am getting overwhelmed by all these new apps. Regarding the WordPress app, I was already feeding my posts into my profile page, so I am not sure about the difference with the new app. I guess it makes it easier for people to leave comments?
marguerite
http://lamarguerite.wordpress.com
I love Facebook. And I am getting overwhelmed by all these new apps. Regarding the WordPress app, I was already feeding my posts into my profile page, so I am not sure about the difference with the new app. I guess it makes it easier for people to leave comments?
marguerite
http://lamarguerite.wordpress.com
So what was the old data black hole
So what was the old data black hole