“Sky isn’t falling” blogger says

Steven Hodson, over at the Inquistr blog, says “the sky isn’t falling” and “What do we get instead? We get people like Robert Scoble who have for the last few days done nothing more than highlight everything bad going on.”

Ahh, yes, ye olde blame the messenger post.

See, all week long I’ve been saying we’re in a death spiral. They argued with me last weekend and on Monday before the market had its worst week ever. Ever.

They are still fighting with me after I’ve been talking with CEOs, investors, normal people, and reading thousands of feeds and watching CNBC nearly around the clock.

Funny that even the experts are wrong. CNBC’s Fast Money show has been calling for the market to go up on every show this week. It, instead, went down down down.

I prefer to tell people the truth as I’m hearing it, even if that truth is tough and nasty.

That said, if you’re watching my posts here I’m looking at this like a hurricane moving across our economy.

It hit New York three weeks ago. Then it moved onto other parts of our economy (auto industry is getting hammered right now, for instance).

My radar screen shows its full effects have not yet been felt in the tech industry for a variety of reasons. But it is headed here.

Now, what happens in a storm? Some trees topple. Some stand tall.

But right now to try to smile and say everything is going great and you should be optimistic is wrong. Sorry, it’s wrong.

It’s time to take steps to make sure your businesses are strong and can withstand the storm. If they aren’t strong, it’s time to fix that and fix that fast.

As the storm passes over us in the next quarter (financial results are still to come, so there’s still a couple of bad quarters to come, particularly with consumer electronics companies and retailers as they get a full sense of how bad the Christmas buying season will be) we’ll certainly see winners and losers.

Last weekend I was really freaked out. I was right to be freaked out.

Today I’m a lot more calm and am “working the problem.”

So, Steven is right too. The truth is often in between two extremes. But I won’t apologize for losing my head on Monday. If you had listened to the optimists and had bought on Monday you would have lost another 18% of your wealth. If you had listened to me and sold you’d have a lot more to buy back in or to use to keep paying your bills over the next year or two.

It’s why I keep asking questions here, too. I don’t have all the answers. Heck, I don’t have many answers at all. But the neat thing about this is you can share your opinions and views of what’s going on and give us ideas for how to ride out the coming storm.

Post a URL if you have some good ones, we’ll all appreciate it.

  • http://poetslife.blogspot.com/ poetslife

    You’re like Jim Cramer’s infotainment…you’re right about one-third of the time. Macroeconomics is not your strong point so I take what you say about the economy with a grain of salt. On technology, however….

  • http://poetslife.blogspot.com poetslife

    You’re like Jim Cramer’s infotainment…you’re right about one-third of the time. Macroeconomics is not your strong point so I take what you say about the economy with a grain of salt. On technology, however….

  • http://brianfrank.ca/ B Frank

    Sorry, it would’ve been more clear for me to write “the panic surrounding *the crisis* is the hurricane.” The point of my comment was that the hurricane metaphor isn’t strong enough to describe the underlying crisis. I certainly don’t deny there is one.

    I’ve been working hard for the past year to develop constructive ways to think and talk about the crisis. I guess I lost my head — like you said you did on Monday. The combatative tone was out of line. It isn’t the way to address our problems.

    Apologies and best regards.

  • http://brianfrank.ca B Frank

    Sorry, it would’ve been more clear for me to write “the panic surrounding *the crisis* is the hurricane.” The point of my comment was that the hurricane metaphor isn’t strong enough to describe the underlying crisis. I certainly don’t deny there is one.

    I’ve been working hard for the past year to develop constructive ways to think and talk about the crisis. I guess I lost my head — like you said you did on Monday. The combatative tone was out of line. It isn’t the way to address our problems.

    Apologies and best regards.

  • http://www.raindropper.com/ Tomi Itkonen

    RR, I was quoting NY Times article written by Casey B. Mulligan (a professor of economics).

    Casey provides an interesting, positive viewpoint, and is a pro.

    Anyway, it seems that the financial situation has become a beast with a mind of its own. Can anybody control it at the moment? Was there a serious design flaw in the system?

  • http://www.raindropper.com Tomi Itkonen

    RR, I was quoting NY Times article written by Casey B. Mulligan (a professor of economics).

    Casey provides an interesting, positive viewpoint, and is a pro.

    Anyway, it seems that the financial situation has become a beast with a mind of its own. Can anybody control it at the moment? Was there a serious design flaw in the system?

  • Jeroen

    I think the reason why people are coming after you for pessimistic reporting, is partly because we only hear your broad economic views when stuff is going badly. If you only report the economic news when it is negative you are adding to the cosmic balance of negativity so I think the complaint that you are fuelling the downward spiral is actually somewhat warranted.

    Please report on how great the financial markets are when all this is over with as much vehemence and my wish for reporting karma is compensated for more than adequately. I do think your insights are as sharp as ever though :-)

  • Jeroen

    I think the reason why people are coming after you for pessimistic reporting, is partly because we only hear your broad economic views when stuff is going badly. If you only report the economic news when it is negative you are adding to the cosmic balance of negativity so I think the complaint that you are fuelling the downward spiral is actually somewhat warranted.

    Please report on how great the financial markets are when all this is over with as much vehemence and my wish for reporting karma is compensated for more than adequately. I do think your insights are as sharp as ever though :-)